Blog Posts Enterprise Architecture (EA)

Service-design: How long is a service?

Blog: Tom Graves / Tetradian

It was my grandmother’s 80th birthday. My parents wanted to make it a special occasion for her and for the family, so they booked us in for a meal at a place called Le Talbooth – then, as now, a decidedly upmarket restaurant beside the River Stour, on the border between Essex and Suffolk counties in south-east England.

Back in those days, Le Talbooth only did a fixed menu, with the only choice between meat or fish, and with everything booked in advance. But one of our extended-family was vegetarian – at that time still regarded as a bit unusual, even a bit eccentric – so we had to warn the restaurant that we needed a different dish in her case.

So come the day, there we all were, in the grand private room of the restaurant. After the starters, out came the main course – meat or fish, as per the pre-agreed plan. And out came one of the serving-staff, who asked, somewhat diffidently, “I understand one of your party is vegetarian?” She duly raised a hand, awaiting the usual tired omelette or baked-potato that was often all that a vegetarian could expect back then. Oh well.

But that wasn’t what came up in this case. Instead, the kitchen had gone wild. They’d gone crazy. They’d obviously had a lot of fun. Because what was wheeled out, with some pride and ceremony, was an entire trolley-load of vegetarian treats – much of it food that most of us had never seen or heard of before, let alone tasted. Wow! I think every one of us turned vegetarian on the spot! – for the day, at least!

That was quite a long time ago – more than four decades ago now, in fact. But the memory of superb service from that restaurant still lives on, even that far back into the past.

Which, by a roundabout route, brings us to a key question for service-designers: how long does a service-instance last? What’s its actual duration?

The usual view of service-instances is organisation-centric:

But as with all business-centrism in business-architecture and enterprise-architecture, that view risks missing the point here – and often dangerously so. An organisation’s value-proposition isn’t solely about its products or services: far more, it’s about how those products or services can help customers, providers, employees and everyone else to reach towards a shared-story – ‘the enterprise’ not as an organisation, but as a literal ‘bold endeavour’, shared with all others in that story’s space. Services are thus a means to reach towards satisfying the drivers for the story:

On the surface, and for the organisation, yes, service-delivery might appear only as the ‘horizontal’ supply-chain path on that diagram above, with the service-instance starting and ending as it transits the boundaries and timelines of the organisation itself. In effect, that’s service viewed solely as ‘how’ and ‘with-what’.

Yet the drivers for the service – the ‘why’ for service – are actually in the shared ‘vertical’ links between each party and the same overarching story, as on that diagram above. That’s how the connection is made: that’s where marketing and branding sit, for example, and why branding is so strongly oriented towards story – towards creating a meaningful story about a means to satisfy a perceived or actual need.

And it’s in that ‘why’ that we also find the criteria for success in service-delivery. We see it especially in experiences such as in our family’s story above, where the expectations of service were not only met, but far exceeded, in ways that – as in our case – may literally ring on down through the generations.

We could probably say much the same, if in less happy ways, about disservices – supposed ‘services’ that fail to deliver to the actual need. For example, consider this (mildly-redacted) item that came up from a US colleague in my Twitter-feed this morning:

Again, the key here is that certain expectations were set, by the organisation’s engagement in that story – and those expectations were not met. Definitely not met. Okay, the disgruntlement there may not sit for decades, as did our contrasting enjoyment of that family-occasion. Yet it still represents a real kurtosis-risk, and one that could well destroy the organisation’s business if left to repeat too often or fester too long – especially in these days of social-media, where a single anticlient-Tweet can easily echo halfway round the world…

So to make sense of the true life-cycle of service-instances, we need to shift our view of services themselves, from an organisation-centric perspective, to the perspective of the service-customer.

(Technically the correct term is ‘service-consumer’, of course – but I strongly object to that term ever being applied to real people!)

In which case, if we use this example above, of my grandmother’s birthday-dinner at Le Talbooth, then:

In effect, the quality of service-delivery continues to be re-assessed, indefinitely, until it is finally forgotten. It’s that factor that drives anticlient-impacts and the like – or, on the positive side, that likewise underlies more directly-measurable impacts such as Net Promoter Score.

Try it: what difference does it make for service-design if you shift the perspective from organisation-centric to customer-centric? Let me know in the comments, perhaps?

Leave a Comment

Get the BPI Web Feed

Using the HTML code below, you can display this Business Process Incubator page content with the current filter and sorting inside your web site for FREE.

Copy/Paste this code in your website html code:

<iframe src="" frameborder="0" scrolling="auto" width="100%" height="700">

Customizing your BPI Web Feed

You can click on the Get the BPI Web Feed link on any of our page to create the best possible feed for your site. Here are a few tips to customize your BPI Web Feed.

Customizing the Content Filter
On any page, you can add filter criteria using the MORE FILTERS interface:

Customizing the Content Filter

Customizing the Content Sorting
Clicking on the sorting options will also change the way your BPI Web Feed will be ordered on your site:

Get the BPI Web Feed

Some integration examples